Welcome to Varda Books!
Need Help? Call us toll-free:
1-866-322-0993
homeMembers Cart`WishMy AccountHelp
eBookShuk Books Software
Register    Sign In    Sign Out | @ PublishersRow.com
Products
Browse All |Hot Off the Press |Top Sellers |Coming Soon | Weekly Special | NEW | Judaic Digital Library  
     Enter Your Special
Offer Code Here:
  
     Search:             Advanced search

   Special Bundles
The War against Israel
G. Alon Second Temple Bookshelf
Hispania Judaica
International Critical Commentaries (ICC): Tanakh (Hebrew Bible)
Jews, Jesus, and the Origin of Christianity: a Jewish Perspective
Judaic Digital Library
Master a Masikhta
New! Hebrew Bible: Scholar's Digital Library 1.2
S.R. Driver - U. Cassuto Collection
Torah: Interactive Bookshelf
     Secure Shopping
 
 
money-back 30 days guarantee
 
   Browse Books
Display Titles/Authors Only
List all A to Z
Ar
Hebrew
Modern political thought
Talmud
Torah/Bible
Torah (Oral)
Rabbinics
Biography/Memoirs
General Jewish-Interest Literature
History
Holocaust
Israel
Jewish Religious Thought
Jewish Education
References
Books in Russian
Christianity
Magic and Occult

The Hebrew University Magnes Press:
מדעי היהדות
היסטוריה
אמנות

The Hebrew University Magnes Press:
Judaism

Bar Ilan University Press:
General
Literature
Judaica & Philosophy
Talmud & Rabbinic Literature
Biblical Studies
Psychology
Interpretation and Culture, edited by Prof. Avi Sagi
THEMA- A Series of Thematological Studies in the Literature of the Jewish People
MAHSHAVOT- A Series for Studies in Jewish Thought in Memory of Isidore Friedman
Critical Horizons

JTSA PRESS:
General
Biography / Memoirs
Christianity
Education
Gender politics / Feminism
Jewish identity
History / Historiography
Halakhah / Law
Philosophy
Torah / Bible
Community / Organizations
   More About
Our Authors
PublishersRow.com
Other Publishers
JEWISH BOOKS

Adobe Acrobat 5.0 or later is required to read our e-books*



Windows PC & Mac OS9/OSX


Jewish Books

Jewish Books
References
Hebrew
Judaism
Judaica
Talmud
Torah/Bible
Torah/Oral

Hebrew Bible


Hebrew Bible

Encyclopedies

Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics

Jewish Encyclopedia

Jewish Encyclopedia
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 1
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 2
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 3
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 4
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 5
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 6
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 7
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 8
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 9
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 10
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 11
The Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 12
The Jewish Encyclopedia, Index Volume

Universal Jewish Encyclopedia

Volume 1, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 2, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 3, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 4, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 5, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 6, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 7, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 8, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 9, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Volume 10, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia
Reading Guide and Index, The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia

All Encyclopedies

PublishersRow > eBookShuk > Books > Talmud > Books


eBook Tractate Berakhos II: Commentary and Study Guide
Larger view

Tractate Berakhos II: Commentary and Study Guide

Author:  Nachman Cohen
Publisher:  Varda Books
Original Publisher:  Torah Lishmah Institute
Published:  2009
Language:  English
Pages:   566


Free Preview I thought it might be of interest to you Add to wish list AddThis Social Bookmark Button
 

Available as:   (for format`s description click on its name)

 

Scholar PDF

$ 39.95 
  BUY NOW

ISBN: 1590459075

File size: 52.541 Mb

 

Library Edition

$ 95.95 
  BUY NOW

ISBN: 1590459075

File size: 52.541 Mb




About the Book -- Tractate Berakhos II: Commentary and Study Guide

Master a Mesikhta Series

The series opens the world of Talmud to English speaking public at the level that few commentaries have done until now. Nachman Cohen allows the reader a rare opportunity to follow the raging Rabbinic debates and the development of Jewish law throughout the ages. Unlike a mere translation, the commentary provides the tools to truly get into Talmud. Each volume contains such an abundance of both basic and in-depth information that even seasoned scholars may find it helpful for both review and as a reference tool.

Tractate Berachos was written and compiled in turbulent times. First the Second Temple was destroyed and then Betar. The Jewish population was displaced from the southern part of the Land of Israel up north. These changing circumstances caused the Rabbis to impose many halakhic decrees which were not received without controversies. Where possible Nachman Cohen explains how the haskafah, or religious and ideological outlook of each Rabbi (ותמשנ שרוש) serves to generate his halakhic stance. Understanding how Rabbis formulated decrees and dealt with changing conditions sheds light on how they would have reacted to some of our modern day dilemmas.

Tractate covers various topics: dreams, prophecy, wisdom, the origin and meaning of brakhos (blessings), Birkas haMazon (Grace after Meals) and Birkas haZimun, the significance of wine for Kiddush, the dispute over the significance of Rosh haShana, the use of asmakhtos, and the meaning and import of the blessing ינשע אלש ה שא (You did not make me a female).



About the Book

About the Author -- Tractate Berakhos II: Commentary and Study Guide

Nachman Cohen ---

Rabbi Nachman Cohen, Director of Torah Lishmah Institute, is the Spiritual Leader of Young Israel Ohab Zedek, of North Riverdale/Yonkers, and Chairman of the Board of the Association of Orthodox Jewish Scientists.


Rabbi Cohen studied in Mesivta Torah Vodaath as well as Yeshivas Karlin Stolin. He received an Sc.M. in Physics from Brown University and a Ph.D. in Philosophy from Boston University.


 

An Excerpt from the Book -- Tractate Berakhos II: Commentary and Study Guide

New Page 48

Meaning of Rosh haShana

Much more is to be gleaned from Talmudic disputes than halakha I'ma'aseh (the normative law). As important as the latter is, one must always seek to understand the hashkafic [religio-philosophic] pillar upon which each view of a dispute is based, because these lend insight into the profound depths of Judaism. Moreover, understanding a diverse position, helps to clarify and illuminate the underpinnings of the view which is normative and thereby makes the observance of that practice more meaningful in that it gives one an opportunity to perform the mitzvah with ״םהב ונווכש תונווכה״ [the intent with which these were performed] by Chazal.

The dispute which follows serves as a typical example. It deals with the prayer-text for the Aseres Y'mei T'shuva (Ten Days of Penitence). Studying it is sure to make one's Rosh haShana more meaningful.

[65] Rabbah b. Chin'na/Rav: Throughout the year a person concludes [the 4th and the 10th blessings of the Sh'moneh Esreh] with the salutation ״שודקה לקה" (the Sanctified God) and ״בהוא ךלמ טפשמו הקדצ" (the King Who loves righteousness and judgment). During the Aseres Y'mei T'shuva, the salutation is ״שודקה ךלמה״ (the King Who is holy) and ״טפשמה ךלמה" (the King [Who presides over] the judgment).

Rashi: This change underscores that during this period God's kingship is manifest through His judgment of the world.

R. Elazar: One who says ״שודקה לקה״ and ״הקדצ בהוא ךלמ טפשמו" fulfills his obligation.

This derives from the verse ״לקהו טפשמב תואבצ ה הבגיו הקדצב שדקנ שודקה״ ("and the Lord of Hosts is exalted through judgment and the Sanctified God is sanctified through righteousness") (Yeshaya 5:16). The latter verse describes God during the Aseres Y'mei T'shuva [for this is when God becomes manifest through judgment] and yet God is described as שודקה לקה.״

G'mara: How has this matter been resolved?

R. Yosef: A person should say ״שודקה לקה״ and ״בהוא ךלמ טפשמו הקדצ.״

Rabbah: He should say ״שודקה ךלמה״ and ״טפשמה ךלמה.״

The halakha follows the view of Rabbah.

While the [medieval] French Rabbis maintain that the dispute between Rav and R. Elazar concerns only the optimal manner in which the 4th and 10th blessings should be concluded, and if one were to say "לקה שודקה״ and ״טפשמו הקדצ בהוא ךלמ״ even Rav would agree that ex post facto this would be acceptable, the prevailing view is that each of these Rabbis staunchly posits his view to the extent that if when praying one veers from his stated position, the Sh'moneh Esrei is invalid and must be recited anew.

So far for the halakhic considerations.

Meta-legal analysis

When studying this dispute [and others of its kind], the student often fails to ask the revealing questions: What is the basis for this dispute? and What leads each Rabbi to advance his viewpoint? In this case, it is more instructive to investigate the latter question first.

At the very end of Tractate Horiyos, the Talmud identifies two types of talmidei chakhamim [Talmudic scholars]: the Sinai and the Oker Harim (Uprooter of Mountains). The Sinai is the encyclopedic scholar who has the entire corpus of Jewish knowledge at his fingertips. The Oker Harim is the scholar who is able to penetrate the core of Biblical and Talmudic law to the extent that through his analysis he can bring new meaning to the law and thereby in some cases seemingly overturn [that is, redefine] existing law. The G'mara reveals that Rabbah was an Oker Harim, whereas R. Yosef was a Sinai.

An appreciation of Rabbah and his role as an Oker Harim is portrayed in the following Talmudic tale: Rabbah b. Nachmeni died through persecution. The events leading up to his death were the following: Informers told the State that Rabbah was responsible for 12,000 Jews not paying their poll-tax because they went to study at his academy during the months of Nisan and Tishri. A royal officer was sent to imprison Rabbah. He fled from Pumbedisa, to Akra, to Agama, to Sahin, to Zarifa, to Ein Damim, back to Pumbetisa ...[and finally] to Agama. There "along with the Heavenly Academy he studied" the laws of n'ga'im (blemishes). The following was studied:

If the raw patch of skin preceded the white hair, the person is tameh (unclean). If the white hair came first, the person is tahor (clean). If the order of appearance is in doubt—

God: He is tahor.
The Heavenly Academy: He is tameh.

They said: Who can resolve this dispute? Rabbah b. Nachmeni, for he is considered a yachid (singular individual) with regard to the law of blemishes.

A messenger was sent to him, but the Angel of Death could not approach him because he was studying Torah continuously. In the meantime, a wind blew through the forest and he mistook this for an oncoming band of soldiers. Thinking that he was about to be arrested, he proclaimed, "Let me die rather than be handed over to the State."

As he was about to die, he proclaimed, "[the blemish discussed is] tahor." Whereupon a bas kol [Heavenly voice] came forth and proclaimed, "Happy be you, Rabbah b. Nachmeni, whose body is "tahor, and whose soul departed tahor."

Bava Metzia 86a

To be sure, this episode requires a great deal of analysis. Yet, our analysis will be limited to what is necessary to clarify the point at hand, namely: How is it possible for angels to dispute with HaShem as to the halakha? Logic dictates that by definition HaShem determines halakha! Moreover, what is meant by the fact that Rabbah b. Nachmeni will resolve this dispute because he is a yachid?

It is to be remembered that halakha is complex and multi-leveled. The doctrine of Eilu v'Eilu Divrei Elokim Chayim teaches that when viewed from different perspectives, the application of the halakha leads to varied conclusions. (See "Axioms and Underpinnings" in my book Mirrors of Eternity) In deciding an halakhic point, a rabbi must decide the halakha from his halakhic perspective. Thus, in the controversy between HaShem and the angels over the status of said blemish, the angels were compelled to rule in accordance with their understanding despite the fact that they knew that HaShem ruled the blemish tahor.


An Excerpt from the Book

Books on "Talmud" Category

Talmud Yerushalmi: A Concordance of Amoraic Terms, Expressions and Phrases, in 3 vols. by Assis Moshe
Tractate Berakhos & Tamid v. I: Commentary and Study Guide by Nachman Cohen
Tractate Sanhedrin: Commentary and Study Guide by Nachman Cohen
Tosefta Ki-Fshutah, 12 vols. by Saul Lieberman
Talmud: Mesekhet B'rakhot, in 4 volumes by Louis Ginzberg
Tractate Rosh Hashana by Nachman Cohen
Esther's Plea by Nachman Cohen
Tractate Berakhos II: Commentary and Study Guide by Nachman Cohen
Tractate Ta'anis: Commentary and Study Guide by Nachman Cohen
Tractate Pesachim: Commentary and Study Guide by Nachman Cohen
Tractate Bava Basra I: Commentary and Study Guide by Nachman Cohen
 


To feature this book on your website*, together with...

(*appropriate also for your online journal, blog, profile page, or on-line forums):

...cover, title, and metadata...

Preview

...title only...

Preview

...cover only, use

Preview






Please Note: To read our e-books, you need Adobe Acrobat or its free Reader (you can get one from here). Once you have installed it, download and install one of our free security plug-in for to unlock the books that you have purchased  .   
If you have not done it already and if your have either PC or Mac, please click here to install now free security plug-in from FileOpen.
For Linux, click here and choose either "Open" or "Run".


Home | Shopping Cart | Contact us | Help

Copyright © 2001-2014 Publishers Row. All rights reserved. Our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

If you see a misspelling or some other mistake on a page, simply select it using your mouse and click Ctrl + Enter. Selected text will be immediately delivered to our webmaster.